Comparing Crittall Windows and Doors to Cost-Effective Alternatives
Key Takeaways
- The brand Crittall is still made today. It’s the Rolls Royce of steel windows and doors. It’s architects and interior designers favourite if their clients have a big enough budget.
- Crittall doors are very expensive. This has led to the growth of alternative Crittall style doors with a similar look and huge cost savings. The market leader being Smart Systems Alitherm Heritage, fabricated in aluminium.
Read on for our comparisons:
When considering an upgrade or installation of new windows and doors, the name Crittall often emerges as a benchmark for quality and aesthetics within the industry. These steel-framed, glazed features are known for their durability, slim profiles, and timeless design.
However, they come with a premium price tag, prompting many consumers to seek out more budget-friendly alternatives. This necessity to balance cost against quality and style has led to a market rich with options, each presenting its own sets of benefits and compromises.
The comparison between Crittall products and their less expensive counterparts involves more than just a cursory look at price tags. It requires an understanding of the materials used, thermal efficiency, security features, and design versatility.
Consumers must also consider the long-term costs associated with maintenance and energy efficiency. While Crittall windows and doors are celebrated for their longevity and performance, it is essential to examine whether the initial investment guarantees a superior product compared to other offerings in the market.
In evaluating these alternatives, one must scrutinise the specifics of manufacturing processes, warranties, and after-sales services, which are pivotal in understanding the overall value proposition. The availability of customisation options and the potential impact on property values can influence a buyer’s decision.
This comparison ultimately seeks to inform homeowners and builders about the various choices available, empowering them to select windows and doors that best suit their budget, stylistic preferences, and practical requirements.
You might also want to read – Problems with Composite Doors: Common Issues and Solutions
Essential Characteristics of Crittall Windows and Doors
Crittall windows and doors are renowned for their distinctive appearance and longevity. Characterised by slim metal frames and a grid-like pattern, they were originally developed during the Victorian era and have since become a staple in both historic restorations and contemporary designs.
Durability is a key feature, with frames typically crafted from hot-rolled galvanised steel. This material affords strength and resistance to warping, rust, and weather-related degradation. Such resilience ensures that Crittall products can provide decades of service with minimal maintenance.
The design of Crittall windows and doors incorporates narrow sightlines, allowing for maximum light entry and unobstructed views. This elegance makes them a popular choice for bringing a sense of openness to a space.
Thermal efficiency is addressed through the incorporation of advanced glazing options and thermal breaks within the frames. Despite their metal construction, Crittall products can achieve commendable insulation properties, reducing heat loss and contributing to a property’s energy efficiency.
Customisation options are abundant, offering varying patterns, finishes, and colours. Clients can tailor their products to specific aesthetic preferences or to meet particular architectural requirements. Safety features include multi-point locking systems for enhanced security, making them a robust option against intruders.
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Material | Hot-rolled, galvanised steel |
| Appearance | Slim profile with grid-like pattern |
| Durability | High resistance to rust, warping, and weathering |
| Natural Light | Narrow sightlines for maximum light entry |
| Thermal Efficiency | Options for advanced glazing and thermal breaks |
| Customisation | Wide range of patterns, finishes, and colours |
| Security | Multi-point locking systems |
Crittall windows and doors carry a legacy of both timeless style and functional design, ideally suited for those seeking a blend of classic and modern in their architecture.
History and Heritage of Crittall
Crittall Windows Ltd, established in 1849 by Francis Henry Crittall in Braintree, Essex, remains emblematic of robust and refined steel-framed windows and doors. The company synthesised Victorian industrial innovation with artistry, leading to widespread use in numerous iconic buildings and private homes.
Key Historic Points:
- 1849: Foundation of Crittall in Essex.
- 1884: An innovative steel-framed window design was patented, securing Crittall’s market position.
- Early 20th Century: Crittall’s became a significant choice in the construction of the renowned Georgian-style homes.
- Post-War Era: They played an integral role in Britain’s rebuilding efforts.
Their unique blend of durability and elegance has garnered Crittall a distinctive reputation. They pioneered the simple, slender steel profiling that enabled maximum light penetration, a principle that has stood the test of time.
Product Evolution:
- 1890s: The ‘Crittall’ metal window evolved from the cast-iron frame to the slimmer wrought-iron version.
- 1920s: Introduction of the revolutionary galvanising process to combat rust.
- Today: Continuation of innovation with energy-efficient designs while maintaining aesthetic integrity.
Crittall’s heritage is not solely based on their product but also on their impact on architecture. They became an integral part of the Art Deco movement and synonymous with the modernist architecture of the 20th century. Their craftsmanship and attention to detail allow them to preserve historic and aesthetic values in contemporary applications.
Benefits of Authentic Crittall Products
Authentic Crittall products offer a distinctive blend of aesthetics, durability, and performance. They provide homeowners and designers with solutions that are not only visually striking but also built to last.
- Aesthetic Appeal: Crittall’s trademark slender profile and minimalist aesthetic impart a chic industrial look, which is highly coveted in contemporary architecture. The design brings together traditional craftsmanship with modern appeal, seamlessly integrating with various architectural styles.
- Durability: Constructed from premium-grade steel and subjected to rigorous manufacturing standards, authentic Crittall windows and doors boast superior strength and longevity. They are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions with minimal maintenance.
- Thermal Efficiency: With advancements in glazing technology, Crittall products have improved thermal performance. Double or triple-glazed options contribute to effective insulation, reducing heat loss and energy costs.
- Customisation: Each Crittall product is bespoke, tailor-made to client specifications. They offer a level of customisation that cheaper alternatives often cannot match. This allows for greater flexibility in design and ensures a perfect fit for unique spaces.
- Acoustic Insulation: The robust construction of genuine Crittall windows and doors also provides enhanced acoustic insulation, creating quieter and more comfortable interior spaces.
- Security: Boasting multi-point locking systems and robust frames, Crittall products offer high levels of security. The sturdy materials and construction also make these windows and doors much more difficult to breach than their cheaper counterparts.
- Resale Value: Installing authentic Crittall products can contribute to the property’s value. Their timeless design and renowned quality are attractive features in the housing market.
In summary, opting for authentic Crittall products guarantees a combination of style, resilience, and performance that cheaper alternatives struggle to match.
Introduction to Cheaper Alternatives
When exploring options for steel-framed windows and doors, one encounters the prominent and esteemed Crittall brand. Renowned for their durability, bespoke craftsmanship, and aesthetic appeal, they serve as an industry benchmark. Yet, their price point is a consideration for those who must adhere to a budget.
In search of cost-effective alternatives, the market offers a variety of brands that provide similar designs at a reduced cost. These alternatives often use more affordable materials or simplified construction methods to lower expenses. They aim to mimic the Crittall style catering to a demand for the industrial look without the associated price tag.
- Aluminium Frames: A common substitute, aluminium is lighter than steel and typically less expensive. They are powder-coated to give a similar finish. Alitherm Heritage is the market leader.
- UPVC Frames: While not as robust or sleek as steel, uPVC flush doors such as those made by Deceunink offer an even lower cost.
Buyers should be aware that these alternatives may not provide the same level of performance in terms of lifespan, acoustic insulation, or thermal efficiency. The choice often rests between balancing cost with the benefits of the higher-end Crittall products. Nevertheless, for those prioritising budget, these alternatives are viable. They serve as a nod to the Crittall style while remaining accessible to a wider audience.
You might also want to read – Can You Paint Composite Doors? Tips for a Fresh New Look
Material Quality and Durability Comparison
When assessing Crittall windows and doors against their less expensive counterparts, a stark contrast in material quality is evident. Crittall products are renowned for their premium-grade steel fabrication, which lends itself to long-lasting performance and strength. Steel, as a material, is highly resistant to warping, shrinking, or corroding when coated correctly, thereby ensuring the longevity of Crittall installations.
In contrast, Crittall style doors often utilise aluminium or uPVC (unplasticised polyvinyl chloride)—materials that are less costly to produce but may not offer the same resilience. For instance, aluminium can be prone to denting and may conduct heat and cold more readily, potentially affecting thermal performance. uPVC, while not susceptible to rust, may degrade under UV exposure and can become discoloured or brittle over time.
| Material | Durability | Thermal Performance | Maintenance Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steel (Crittall) | Excellent against deformation and rust | Good with proper glazing; moderate without | Low; occasional painting or coating |
| Aluminium | Good; liable to denting | Varies; generally better than steel | Low; anodised finishes enhance resilience |
| uPVC | Fair; UV sensitive | Good; natural insulation properties | Low; susceptible to discolouration |
It’s important to note that advances in technology have improved the performance of both aluminium and uPVC, with treatments and coatings that enhance their durability. Nevertheless, they generally fall short of the robustness and expected service life offered by steel-made products. Lastly, the craftsmanship seen in Crittall manufacturing typically reflects a superior quality that is difficult for more budget-conscious alternatives to match.
Energy Efficiency and Insulation
When assessing the energy efficiency and insulation of Crittall windows and doors in comparison to less expensive alternatives, it is imperative to examine the materials used and the design sophistication.
Crittall Products often employ a steel framework, renowned for its durability and slim profile, allowing for greater glass surface area. However, steel is a conductor of heat, which can pose a challenge in terms of insulation:
- Glazing: Crittall windows typically feature double or triple glazing, which significantly improves thermal performance.
- Thermal Breaks: Modern Crittall products include thermal breaks within the frame to reduce heat transfer.
Cheaper Alternatives may use uPVC or aluminium frames. These materials differ in their insulation properties:
- uPVC Frames: They are generally good insulators and reduce heat loss, though they may lack the same aesthetic appeal.
- Aluminium Frames: Similar to steel, aluminium conducts heat but can include thermal breaks to enhance insulation. What is the best aluminium Crittall style door? The market leader is Alitherm Heritage from Smart Systems. They were the first system house to replicate the look of the original Crittall doors.
In terms of U-values, Crittall windows typically achieve a U-value ranging from 1.4 to 1.8 W/m²K, while cheaper alternatives can vary extensively based on their construction and design. A lower U-value indicates better insulation.
The following are key insulation features for both product types:
| Feature | Crittall Windows | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Frame Material | Steel with thermal breaks | uPVC/Aluminium (thermal breaks optional) |
| Glazing Options | Double/Triple | Typically double |
| Typical U-value (W/m²K) | 1.4 to 1.8 | Variable |
Ultimately, consumers must weigh the initial investment against long-term savings in energy bills. While the cost of Crittall windows and doors might be higher, their energy efficiency can be on par with or better than that of cheaper alternatives, depending on the installation and specific product features.
Aesthetic and Design Considerations
When examining the aesthetic and design aspects of Crittall windows and doors in comparison with less expensive alternatives, the distinctive characteristics become evident. Crittall products are renowned for their slim profiles and industrial-chic appearance, which has become a staple in both traditional and modern architectural designs.
Design Authenticity:
- Crittall: Traditional steel-framed design; often replicated but unmatched in its authentic look.
- Alternatives: May imitate the design but can lack the finer details that give Crittall its specific charm.
Visual Impact:
- Crittall: Provides a dramatic statement with slender lines and maximum glass area.
- Alternatives: Generally have thicker frames, which may reduce the glass-to-frame ratio.
Customisation:
- Crittall: Offers extensive customisation options, including a range of colours and finishes.
- Alternatives: Customisation varies; some may offer similar options, but typically with limitations.
Critically, one must remember that while less expensive alternatives can provide a similar look, there is often a compromise in the crispness of lines and the overall finish quality. Lower-cost options may also feature a limited colour palette and fewer finish options, potentially affecting the final design outcome.
In terms of heritage and period properties, proprietors might prefer Crittall for its historical accuracy, which can be crucial in conservation areas or listed buildings. Alternative products may not comply with the stringent regulations governing such properties.
It’s imperative to consider the implications of material and design quality on the long-term appearance and maintenance. Crittall’s robust construction and finish might age more gracefully, whereas cheaper alternatives could show their age sooner due to materials or build quality.
Installation Complexity and Professional Requirements
When installing Crittall windows and doors, the process is recognised for its precision and the need for a high level of skill. These installations typically require trained professionals who are experienced with the system’s unique specifications. The fit and finish are imperative to ensure proper function, longevity, and aesthetics. In contrast, cheaper alternatives might offer a simpler installation process, but the quality and precision may not compare.
Installation criteria for Crittall and its alternatives include:
- Measurement Accuracy: It’s crucial for measurements to be precise to avoid potential issues with structural integrity.
- Specialised Tools: Crittall installations often need specific tools for correct fitting, whereas cheaper options may use standard tools.
Skilled Labour: Professionals familiar with steel frames are generally needed for Crittall, whereas alternatives may not require this level of specialisation.
| Feature | Crittall Installation | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Skill Level Required | High (specialised training) | Variable (often lower) |
| Tools Needed | Specialised tools | Standard tools |
| Time for Installation | Longer due to complexity | Typically shorter |
| Professional Requirement | Certified Crittall installer recommended | Can be installed by general contractors |
| Finish and Fit | Precision essential for performance | Less critical, varies by product |
The use of proper materials and adherence to installation guidelines is vital for durability and functionality. Although the initial cost for professional installation of Crittall windows and doors can be considerable, it is important to balance this against the potential longevity and seamless operation benefits that come from precise installation. Cheaper alternatives may not require such a rigorous process, potentially leading to reduced upfront costs but possibly resulting in higher maintenance needs or shorter lifespans.
Maintenance and Longevity
Crittall windows and doors are renowned for their durability. Constructed from galvanised steel, they typically offer a life expectancy in excess of 60 years when properly maintained. Their polyester powder-coated finish is applied under controlled conditions, resulting in a resilient layer that resists weathering and requires minimal upkeep — usually a simple wash-down to remain in prime condition.
In contrast, cheaper alternatives may employ materials such as PVCu or softer metals that can degrade more quickly over time, particularly under harsh environmental conditions. Maintenance for these materials often involves periodic painting or sealing to prevent deterioration, which may be required every few years.
| Feature | Crittall Windows and Doors | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Galvanised steel | PVCu/Aluminium |
| Finish | Polyester powder coating | Paint/Anodised coating |
| Life Expectancy | >60 years | Approximately 20-30 years |
| Upkeep | Occasional wash-down | Occasional wash-down |
The initial higher investment in Crittall products can be offset by their longer lifespan and reduced maintenance requirements. They resist warping and twisting, features that keep them functional and aesthetically appealing with less frequent repairs or adjustments. While alternatives might initially be cost-effective, they may incur additional maintenance costs and typically warrant replacement sooner than Crittall windows and doors, affecting their overall value proposition in terms of longevity.
Cost Analysis: Initial Investment vs Long-Term Value
Crittall windows and doors are recognised for their durability and timeless style. However, their cost is considerably higher compared to many cheaper alternatives. What are Crittall doors prices? An initial investment for Crittall might range from £1,000 to £3,000 per square metre, whereas other materials such as uPVC could be as low as £300 to £500 per square metre.
Long-term value is an integral consideration. Crittall products are known to last up to 50 years with minimal maintenance. Their resilience to weather and wear offers homeowners extended longevity compared to cheaper materials, which may last only 15 to 25 years before needing replacement.
The cost of ongoing maintenance must be included in the long-term financial outlook. uPVC windows ocaisionally require replacement of seals, while Crittall’s steel frames often need only regular cleaning and occasional paint touch-ups.
Energy efficiency also affects long-term value. Crittall windows with double or triple glazing can reduce energy bills by retaining heat, while less expensive alternatives may result in higher heating costs over time. Energy efficiency ratings must be examined — Crittall often achieves a ‘B’ rating or higher, in contrast to lower ratings for some cheaper options.
Lastly, property value impact should be assessed. Properties with Crittall installations might see a more significant increase in value due to their aesthetic appeal and the prestige associated with the brand. Cheaper alternatives, while effective, typically do not add the same level of value to a property.
| Initial Cost (per sq. metre) | Longevity | Maintenance | Energy Efficiency | Potential Property Value Increase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crittall: £1,000 – £3,000 | Up to 50 years | Low | High (B rating or higher) | High |
| uPVC: £300 – £500 | 15-25 years | Medium | Variable | Moderate |
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
When comparing Crittall windows and doors with their cheaper counterparts, the environmental impact and sustainability are important aspects to consider.
Materials: Crittall products are known for being made from premium steel, a material that is highly durable and recyclable. Steel can often be recycled multiple times without loss of quality, meaning that at the end of their long life cycle, Crittall windows and doors can be melted down and repurposed effectively. Cheaper alternatives may use materials such as uPVC, which has a shorter lifespan and is less sustainable due to difficulties in recycling and the environmental cost of production.
| Feature | Crittall Windows and Doors | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Material Recyclability | High (steel) | Variable (often lower) |
| Lifespan | Longer | Shorter |
| Production Environmental Cost | Lower (recyclable) | Higher |
Energy Efficiency: They also typically offer better insulation due to the quality of the materials and construction, although advancements in cheaper products are narrowing this gap. This means fewer carbon emissions from heating and cooling homes, as well as long-term cost savings on energy bills for the consumer.
Manufacturing: The manufacturing process of Crittall windows is subject to strict environmental regulations which often entail less pollution and waste. Manufacturers of cheaper alternatives might not follow the same stringent standards, potentially leading to a greater environmental impact.
In summary, the environmentally conscious consumer might find Crittall windows and doors to be more sustainable in the long run due to their durability, recyclability, and energy efficiency, despite a higher initial investment.
Security Features of Windows and Doors
When evaluating the security features of windows and doors, Crittall products often stand out for their robust construction. Crittall windows and doors are manufactured with galvanised steel, a material renowned for its strength and durability. This construction greatly enhances security, deterring potential break-ins due to its resilience against forced entry.
In contrast, cheaper alternatives may utilise materials such as uPVC or aluminium, which can be reinforced but may not inherently match the strength of steel. These materials might feature multi-point locking systems and internal beading to prevent the removal of glass from the outside, which are essential security measures.
| Feature | Crittall | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Galvanised Steel | uPVC/Aluminium |
| Locking Mechanisms | Advanced, integrated systems | Standard multi-point |
| Glass Security | Laminated/toughened options | Often optional upgrades |
| Frame Resilience | High resistance to deformation | Varied, depending on construction |
Security glazing is another aspect where Crittall maintains high standards. They offer options for laminated or toughened glass, which are less likely to shatter upon impact. Whilst cheaper alternatives might provide similar types of glass, they are sometimes offered as additional options rather than standard.
It’s important to note that various standards and certifications, such as PAS 24 or Secured by Design, apply to both premium and more affordable options, ensuring a base level of security features are met. Consumers should verify that the products they consider adhere to these standards, regardless of the price point.
Resale Value and Property Appeal
When assessing the impact of Crittall windows and doors versus their less costly counterparts, one must consider their influence on property appeal and potential resale value. Crittall products are recognised for their durability and timeless aesthetic, which can significantly enhance the desirability of a property. In contrast, cheaper alternatives may lack in both these areas.
The choice of windows and doors influences first impressions. A home fitted with Crittall products often conveys a sense of quality and style, traits that prospective buyers or tenants may find attractive. This appeal can translate into a higher resale value or rental price.
| Feature | Crittall Windows and Doors | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Resale Value Contribution | High | Variable |
| Durability | Long-lasting | Less durable |
| Aesthetic Appeal | Timeless design | Style may vary |
| Maintenance Over Time | Less | More |
Homeowners should not overlook the long-term cost benefits. While the initial investment in Crittall may be higher, the need for fewer replacements and lower maintenance can offer savings over time. In addition, energy efficiency and security features in quality products may attract environmentally conscious buyers, further enhancing resale value.
In summary, the perceived value of Crittall windows and doors can lead to a beneficial impact on both the immediate appeal and long-term financial return of a property, whereas cheaper alternatives may not provide the same level of benefit or could potentially detract from a property’s marketability.
Customer Service and Warranty Differences
When assessing the distinction between Crittall windows and doors and their less expensive counterparts, the customer service and warranty offerings are significant factors. Crittall is renowned for its premier customer service experience. Clients often report receiving personalised attention and prompt responses to inquiries. In comparison, budget alternatives might not offer the same level of service, occasionally resulting in longer wait times and a more generic approach to customer support.
Warranty length is a crucial point of difference. Crittall products typically come with a substantial manufacturer’s warranty, lasting up to 20 years for certain elements. This reflects confidence in product longevity and a commitment to quality. Cheaper alternatives often have shorter warranty periods, ranging from 5 to 10 years, suggesting a variation in product life expectancy and construction quality.
A comparative overview:
| Feature | Crittall | Cheaper Alternatives |
|---|---|---|
| Customer Service | Personalised, prompt | Generic, potential delays |
| Warranty Length | Up to 20 years | 5 to 10 years |
| Warranty Scope | Comprehensive, including installation | Often limited, may exclude installation |
| After-Sales Support | Thorough, with a focus on customer satisfaction | Variable, often less robust |
After-sales support is another aspect where Crittall tends to outperform. They offer consistent support and assistance post-purchase, which can include installation checks and maintenance advice. In contrast, support from manufacturers of more economical alternatives is often seen as less thorough, and at times, customers may be directed to third-party service providers for additional assistance. It’s imperative for customers to have clarity on these differences as they can impact long-term satisfaction and the overall value proposition of their purchase.
Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision
When choosing between Crittall windows and doors and their less expensive alternatives, buyers should weigh several factors.
Quality and Durability: Crittall products are renowned for their superior quality and longevity. They often come with extended warranties and require less maintenance. In contrast, budget-friendly options may have shorter lifespans and could incur higher maintenance costs over time.
Cost: There is a significant price difference, with Crittall being the premium option. However, it’s crucial to consider long-term expenses, as initial savings with cheaper alternatives might be offset by additional costs down the line.
Aesthetics: Both options offer a range of styles, but Crittall is distinguished by its classic, slim profile. While alternatives can mimic this look, differences in materials may affect the visual outcome.
Resale Value: Properties with Crittall installations may benefit from higher resale values, as they are often sought-after features. Cheaper alternatives might not have the same impact on property value.
Environmental Impact: Crittall’s commitment to sustainability through recyclable materials and energy-efficient designs may appeal to environmentally conscious consumers. Budget alternatives may not always meet the same environmental standards.
One must consider these factors in relation to individual priorities, such as budget constraints, design preferences, and environmental concerns. A careful assessment will support a well-informed decision that aligns with the buyer’s long-term objectives and personal values.
FAQ’s
What is the best aluminium Crittall style door?
The market leader is Alitherm Heritage from Smart Systems. They were the first system house to replicate the look of the original Crittall doors.
What is a Crittall Style door?
It’s a close match to the original steel doors usually with slim glazing bars. They can be made in steel, uPVC or aluminium.
Hello, I’m Keith Jones. I’m the author and head of content here of door and window guide. I’ve been in the window and door industry for over 10 years in the UK and North America. I’ve had quite a few roles during my career mainly in Worldwide sales. I’m now semi retired so I thought I’d put my knowledge to good use educating people about all they might need to know about door and window related topics.
